top of page

Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler: Which Cuts Carbon Emissions?

localplumber2001
Nov 9
5 min read

Last Updated: 8 November 2026

Quick Summary

A heat pump cuts carbon emissions substantially for most homes, because it produces no direct on-site emissions and runs on electricity. A gas boiler burns gas on site and releases carbon dioxide from its flue. The size of the saving depends on your insulation, system design and the carbon intensity of the grid.

  • A heat pump produces no direct on-site emissions, unlike a gas boiler.

  • A heat pump's footprint falls as the UK grid draws more power from renewables.

  • Check your seasonal performance factor (SPF) to judge a heat pump's efficiency.

  • Improving insulation is usually the most effective way to cut heating emissions.

  • Base any emissions estimate on your actual gas consumption from your bills.

Is a heat pump right for your home?

Heatgeek Wales designs MCS-certified air source heat pump systems for homes across Wales.

Table of Contents

How Heat Pumps and Gas Boilers Produce Emissions

Heat pumps and gas boilers both heat homes, but they produce emissions in very different ways. A gas boiler burns natural gas on site, releasing carbon dioxide from the flue as it runs. A heat pump uses electricity to move heat from outside air into the home, so its emissions depend mainly on how the electricity was generated. Heat pumps are powered by electricity and produce no direct on-site emissions.

An outdoor air source heat pump unit with two fans mounted on a concrete pad beside a cream rendered house with a grey tiled roof.

The gap between the two comes down to the efficiency of the heat pump and the carbon intensity of the grid. Our view is that the heat pump option cuts emissions substantially for most homes, though the size of the saving depends on local conditions. LG's comparison of heat pump and gas boiler emissions

Gas Boiler Carbon Emissions Per Year

A gas boiler's annual emissions depend on how much heat the home needs and how efficiently the boiler converts gas into warmth. Most of the carbon comes from the gas burned during the heating season, so a poorly insulated home with a large heat demand will produce more emissions than a well-insulated one.

Running figures vary widely from home to home, so we avoid quoting a single annual number here. For a closer look at real heat pump savings compared with a gas boiler, see our breakdown of running costs and what decides your figure. A reliable estimate needs your actual gas consumption from your bills, which you can convert into emissions using the official UK conversion factors. UK government greenhouse gas conversion factors for company reporting

Heat Pump Carbon Footprint and the Electricity Grid

A heat pump's carbon footprint is tied closely to the electricity grid. As the UK grid draws more power from renewables, the emissions from running a heat pump fall. Before you go further, check the planning permission requirements for a heat pump that may apply to your property. This is why the same heat pump can have a lower footprint today than it would have a decade ago.

Grid emissions also vary by time of day and season, so the comparison is not fixed. International Energy Agency analysis of heat pump emissions shows that heat pumps still deliver lower greenhouse gas emissions than gas boilers even when electricity is relatively carbon-intensive. Our recommendation is to check the grid trend alongside your own usage when comparing options.

Heat Pump Seasonal Performance Factor Explained

The seasonal performance factor (SPF) measures how much useful heat a heat pump delivers over a full year compared with the electricity it uses. An SPF of 3 means the system produces three units of heat for each unit of electricity. A higher SPF means lower running costs and lower emissions.

Performance depends on the system design, the flow temperature and how well the home is insulated. Heat pumps tend to perform best with lower flow temperatures, which is why we design systems around the specific heat loss of each property. CarbonCrux comparison of heat pump and gas boiler carbon footprints

Pros and Cons of Heat Pumps and Gas Boilers

The table below summarises how the two systems compare on the factors that matter most when deciding. If you live in a home without gas, you can read about which air source heat pump system suits homes without gas.

A black air source heat pump unit with two fans sits on a paved base in gravel beside a cream-painted house wall and window.

Factor

Heat Pump

Gas Boiler

Direct on-site emissions

None

Yes, from burning gas

Running emissions

Depend on grid electricity

Depend on gas use

Typical efficiency

Delivers several units of heat per unit of electricity

Converts gas to heat with lower efficiency

Installation

Often needs a larger outdoor unit and upgrades

Usually a like-for-like swap

Lifespan and upkeep

Regular servicing required

Regular servicing required

Heat pump cons: higher upfront installation requirements, and performance depends on insulation and system design.

Gas boiler pros: lower upfront cost and a familiar, simple replacement.

Gas boiler cons: direct carbon emissions and exposure to gas price rises.

How to Reduce Home Heating Emissions Further

Whichever system you use, a few steps reduce emissions further. Improving insulation is usually the most effective, because it cuts the heat you need to produce. Draught-proofing, loft insulation and cavity wall insulation all help, and so does setting heating schedules to match when you are home.

For heat pumps, lower flow temperatures and a correctly sized system make a large difference to performance. We see the best results when insulation and system design are considered together.

Booking Your Heat Pump Assessment in Wales

If you want to know how a heat pump would perform in your home, the first step is a proper assessment of your property's heat loss. At Heatgeek Wales, our MCS-certified engineers design air source heat pump systems around the specific needs of each home. Book your heat pump assessment to find out what suits your property.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do heat pumps produce fewer carbon emissions than gas boilers?

In most cases, yes. Heat pumps generally produce lower greenhouse gas emissions than a gas boiler, even where electricity is relatively emissions-intensive. The size of the saving depends on how clean the electricity supply is, so the reduction grows as the grid decarbonises. Heatgeek Wales can estimate how a heat pump would compare with your current system once your property has been assessed.

How much CO₂ does a gas boiler produce each year?

The annual figure depends on how much heat your home uses, the efficiency of the boiler and the fuel it burns. Most of the emissions come from burning natural gas during the heating season and when producing hot water. Rather than relying on a generic number, the most reliable approach is to use your own gas meter readings and compare them with the emissions factors for natural gas. An assessment of your property can give you a figure specific to your home.

Does a heat pump's carbon footprint depend on the electricity supply?

Yes. A heat pump runs on electricity, so its emissions depend on how that electricity is generated. As the UK grid includes more renewable generation, the carbon footprint of a heat pump falls. Heat pumps also deliver several units of heat for each unit of electricity used, which is why their emissions are generally lower than a gas boiler even on today's grid. The seasonal performance factor of the installed system is a key part of this calculation.

What is a seasonal performance factor and why does it matter?

The seasonal performance factor (SPF) measures how much useful heat a heat pump delivers over a full year compared with the electricity it consumes. A higher SPF means less electricity is needed for the same heat, which lowers both running costs and emissions. Design choices such as flow temperature, radiator sizing and controls all influence the SPF, so a well-designed system matters as much as the equipment itself.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page